The 3 Best Mule Saddles in 2019 – Everything you need to know

Professionals Review Best Saddles for Mules on the Market

If you are reading this article, then equine adventures are for sure one of your interests. We have all felt the pain of an ill-fitting, uncomfortable saddle during long trail rides – and probably so has our mule.

Buying a saddle is not an easy choice. There are all sorts of questions that need to be answered – Is it comfortable? Is it durable? Is it the right fit for my mule? That’s why we have spent countless hours of research to find the 3 best mule saddles out in the market. I strongly recommend that you read this buyer’s guide before making a purchase.

Below you can see a table showing our top 3 choices when it comes to mule saddles. Each saddle has been carefully researched and scored according to its features, quality and price.

Product Score Price
Saddlery Colorado All Around Saddle 4.8/5 $$$
Cashel Company Drover Saddle 4.7/5 $$$$
King Series Mesquite Mule Saddle 4.4/5 $$

So now let’s look at each one in more detail – weighing the pros and cons.

#1 Saddlery Colorado All Around Saddle – Classic and Traditional!

The Colorado All Around Saddle features a deep seat with a 4 ½ inches cantle and a stamped cheyenne roll providing you with the most comfortable riding experience. Made with high quality leather this saddle can handle long trail rides and all kinds of riding adventures; ideal for both the amateur and the expert.

The seat is available in a 14″, 14.5″, 15″, 15.5″, 16″, 16.5″ and 17″ – giving you enough choice to opt for the size that fits you and your mule best.

This saddle is a lightweight fit, coming at 34 lbs, ensuring a comfortable riding experience for hours on end.

Pros Cons
  • Deep pocketed seat
  • High quality leather
  • Slimline ⅞ inskirt  “C” Rigging
  • Border Tooled, Oiled and Polished
  • Wide choice of seat size
  • Pricey
  • Heavyweight



#2 Cashel Company Drover Saddle – Elegant and Comfortable

For those perfectionists out there, paying attention to every little detail … this saddle is for you! The Drover saddle is made out of high quality Hermann Oak skirting leather that guarantees a long future; but yet features a full padded seat to provide you with the utmost comfort on long rides and trails.

The AXIS™ tree provides full, even contact to best fit your horse and ensures optimum balance.

If this is something your budget can buy, then it is definitely a GO option.

Pros Cons
  • Luxurious look
  • 4” Monel wide stirrups
  • 100%, all natural sheep wool and soft leather latigos
  • Full padded seat
  • Expensive



#3 King Series Mesquite Mule Saddle – Good Value for Money

If you are looking for a soft and shock-absorbing saddle at an affordable price, the King Series Mesquite Mule saddle is an ideal choice.

This saddle has flatter bars to eliminate rocking – making it a comfortable choice for you and your mule during long rides. It features a dropped double D in skirt rigging and a 5” cantle.

The seat comes only at 15”, 16” and 17” size – so options are a bit limited. Yet, if you are low on a budget this is definitely good value for your money

Pros Cons
  • Budget-friendly
  • Tough 1 Quick change buckles
  • Comfortable
  • Neoprene in skirts
  • Limited choice of seat size
  • Heavyweight


Choosing the best saddle – Factors to consider

  1. Compatibility

Probably the most common question would be “Will a horse saddle fit?” The simple answer is NO.  Although a horse and a mule look much alike, their muscle and bone structure are very different; so using a general horse saddle will only do damage to your beloved animal. And be sure – your mule will darn sure let you know about it.

  1. Comfort

What’s the one biggest factor when it comes to riding comfort for most of us? Yes… you got that right, the saddle. Getting saddle comfort right can make a huge difference between plotting along happily on your trail ride and hating every single second. That’s why you need to be extra careful on the fit, shape, and design when choosing your next mule saddle.

  1. Seat Size

Although choosing the right saddle size would seem to be pretty logical, many riders overlook this factor. Taking into account your height and weight, ensure that you are choosing the right seat size for your riding needs. Also, do not forget to pay attention to your mule’s back length – a really long saddle seat may put too much pressure if your mule’s back is fairly short.

  1. Durability

if strolling around muddy fields and gloomy trails are your thing, then steer clear of cheal leathers and go for something harder wearing. You definitely do not want your perfect saddle let you down long before the saddle life is out, so make sure the quality you are buying guarantees durability and longevity.

  1. Cost

If riding takes up much time of your week, then you will want to invest in a high-quality saddle that will hold up for the long run. Yet, if you are an amateur who enjoys a ride every blue moon, then you may opt for the more affordable option that will still do the job. That’s why we have provided you with the best saddles – suitable for all budgets.

  1. Look

It might not be the most significant factor, but it is important enough to influence your decision over which saddle to choose. There are no rules when it comes to a saddle’s appearance – it is entirely up to personal choice and preference. Fortunately, the variety in colors and designs nowadays is vast – so you have a lot of options to choose from.



Do your homework before you buy a saddle and weigh all these factors provided in this article. Your saddle is probably the most expensive piece of equipment that you will purchase – so make sure it’s a wise choice. If you have read this article carefully, then it should not be that much of a hard decision.